This review is for an earlier edition of the book. A newer edition has been released: Paying for College, 2020 Edition: Everything You Need to Maximize Financial Aid and Afford College. Read on for a review of an earlier edition.
Paying for College Without Going Broke: 2009 Edition by Kalman A. Chany (with Geoff Martz) – forward by former US President Bill Clinton
Any book that can save you money on college costs seems like it should be worth its weight in gold. Does this book, published by the Princeton Review and the Clinton Foundation, live up to that?
The forward by former President Bill Clinton is worth a read. It’s short (page and a half) and I actually learned a lot about him from it. Did you know that he was the first person in his family to go to college? And that it was his administration that created AmeriCorps?
Special message to first-generation college students and their parents:
This mini-chapter explains how college admissions should be a collaborative effort between parents and children, and the importance of being honest on financial aid forms. It also gets into dispelling financial aid myths, and how to decide if college is the best next-step.
Who gets the most aid? The people who understand the financial aid process. This chapter (and parts of the book) demonizes the FAO – Financial Aid Officer. This person is your opponent in the “war” to get as much aid as possible. Think of it like a chess match – you’re opposing forces, both governed by strict rules.
Part One: Understanding the Process
Chapter One: Overview
The basics of the FAFSA and determining “need.” The financial aid package and the three types of aid: grants (and scholarships), work-study, and loans. There’s a great suggestion here to have a “financial safety school.” There’s also a guide to the rest of the book, including a disclaimer that this is not about lying or cheating the system, but understanding it in order to take advantage and save money, while still following all of the rules.
Part Two: How to Take Control of the Process
Chapter Two: Long-Term Strategies for Paying for College
Basically, this chapter is “What to do if college is more than two years away.” Why save at all? How much money will you need (an examination into compound interest)?
Should money be put into the child’s name? Answer: “If you have any hope of financial aid, never put money in the child’s name.” Under the federal formula used by the FAFSA, parents are expected to use 5.65% of their assets to pay for their child’s college each year, but children’s assets are assessed at a whopping 20%! And once the money is in the child’s name, it’s extremely difficult to put it back under a parent’s name.
What if you’re fairly sure you won’t qualify for financial aid? Keep your money however you like, but be sure – there’s a worksheet in the back of the book to help you determine whether you really will qualify for aid, or not. And you might be surprised.
Types of investments for a college fund: Diversity is key here. There’s a quick guide to: stock mutual funds, high-yield bonds, normal-yield bonds, EE savings bonds, tax-free municipal bonds, as well as Cloverdale ESAs and 529 plans.
Finally, specifics on what to do if you have 15 years, 10 years, 5 years, or 2 years to go.
Chapter Three: Short-Term Strategies for Receiving More Financial Aid
Understanding the interplay between filing taxes and filling out the financial aid form. The most important concept here is the “base-year” – the tax year before the student enters college, which sets the tone for how much aid the student will receive. For example, if a student will start their freshman year in 2009, then the base year is tax year 2008. How taxes (for the parents, especially) are filed for 2008 will be critical in determining how much aid that student receives. There is also an explanation as to which assets will be looking at when calculating financial aid – in other words, where you should keep your money, and where you shouldn’t, for financial aid purposes.
Chapter Four: How to Pick Colleges
Two important things to think about in this chapter. First of all, there should be an open dialogue between parents and students about what college is going to cost, and what the family can afford. I never had this conversation, and now I have $42,000 in debt to shoulder because of it. I’m not blaming my parents, but rather showing how this is a very important thing to do to avoid a situation like mine. Secondly, you don’t really know what aid you’re going to get from a school until after you’ve applied to the school and applied for aid – some schools that are expensive on paper may give more attractive aid packages than public schools. There are a lot of factors that go into it, so applying to several schools is highly encouraged.
Chapter Five: What the Student Can Do
This chapter disappointed me immensely. As a student who was in full control of the entire college process (planning, applying, applying for aid, and paying the bills), I find it disheartening that this chapter is only six pages long. Students with situations similar to mine will have to “translate” the rest of the advice, meant for parents, into what they can personally do for themselves. But the obvious takeaway is that the financial aid process is skewed toward families where the parents are actively involved, and students will do a lot better if they can get their parents to read this book and act on the information. This chapter covers the obvious: get good grades, take AP classes, do well on the SATs, and consider alternatives, like starting at a cheaper school and transferring, taking a gap year, or going to school part-time.
Chapter Six: State Aid
Another short chapter, but this makes sense – the book would be enormous if it tried to cover the intricacies of each and every state aid program. But the main takeaway here is to pay attention to what aid is offered by your state – you may qualify even if you don’t qualify for any federal aid. There is a listing in this chapter of state agencies and their contact information.
Part Three: Filling Out the Standardized Forms
This part goes into what you should do to prepare for filling out financial aid forms, including what documents you’ll need and when you should file. The explanations, question by question, for the FAFSA and PROFILE are simply awesome. This can help to clear up questions you may have about the questions asked on these forms.
Part Four: The Offer
A guide-within-a-guide to understanding the different types of aid that colleges list on “offer letters.” This is very helpful, because this seems to be the second most confusing part of the aid process (#1 most confusing being those forms from the last section). This part also deals with negotiating the aid package, if you’re not offered enough.
Chapter Seven: Innovative Payment Options
This chapter probably isn’t what you think. The ideas listed here include: transferring in later (again), cooperative education (a big one at the college I went to), short-term prepayment, ROTC, outside scholarships (which account for less than 5% of the financial aid in the US), borrowing from retirement plans, loan forgiveness (usually in exchange for community service), moral obligation loans, and payment plans.
Chapter Eight: Managing Your Debt
From the process of picking a lender to how to pay off the loans once you have them. There’s a guide to different repayment plans, and a brief explanation on consolidation, loan discharge, and cancellation. This chapter is a little light, as well, but let’s face it – paying off student loans is a different topic entirely than paying for college in the first place. It’s information best left for another book.
Chapter Nine: Special Topics
Got a case of divorced or separated parents? The rules for that situation can make your head spin: blended families add a ton of dimension to the financial aid process. This book handles the details with grace – I’ve never seen such a good explanation of what to do when dealing with blended families in the financial aid process. Other “special topics” include: transfer and graduate students; aid for being academically gifted, an athlete, or a minority; running a business or a farm; recently unemployed workers; independent students; establishing state residency; early decision/action/notification/read; aid for older students; international students; foreign tax returns; study abroad programs; and (my favorite) a note to financial professionals insisting that they learn about the financial aid process in order to better serve their clients.
Chapter Ten: Less Taxing Matters
An overview on how changes in tax laws (and other laws) have affected the financial aid process and saving for college this year. There’s some good news and some bad news here, as well as some things that are phasing out.
Chapter Eleven: Looking for a Financial Aid Consulting Service
If you’ve decided this is all more than you want to deal with, this chapter will take you through how to find and choose a consultant, including what questions to ask a professional before you pay for advice.
Chapter Twelve: Future Trends
More of a chapter of interest than useful information. Although, if you’re a parent of a young child, these changes will be important to you in the coming years.
Part Five: Worksheets and Forms
Yep, it’s worksheets, forms, and a glossary. And you’re done!
Recommendations by Age Group
Is this just a book for snobby rich parents to avoid draining the trust fund in order to pay for their rich kids’ college educations? No. Reading this book, I see several things that I could have done over the past fives years to lessen my loan burden and make the whole process easier on myself. Colleges do not always meet you halfway, even when you’ve demonstrated extraordinary need. I could have benefited from this book (or one like it) at the beginning of my college career.
High school: Although most of the information here is targeted at parents, you could benefit a lot from this book. Like I said earlier, you can benefit the most if you can get your parents to read it as well, and get them to act on the information in it. Highly recommended.
College: If you read this book, you may feel like the ship has sailed on a lot of what you could have done to make college cheaper. But there’s still time, and if you’re struggling or concerned about the amount of debt you’re taking on, this book is well worth a read (again, even more so if you can get your parents involved). Recommended.
20-something: Unless you’re already thinking about college for Junior, there’s not much here for you, but you probably already knew that. Not necessarily recommended.
20-something or older with young children: The part you find relevant in this book is short compared to the whole, but useful. This probably shouldn’t be the only book you read about saving for college, but there’s certainly some good information to pick out of chapter two, and maybe even chapter three. Recommended.
Parents of high school students: Get this book and read it right now. The sooner, the better. Highly recommended.
The giveaway is now closed! You can buy Paying for College Without Going Broke on Amazon.com. Or, you can preorder the 2010 edition!
Nate @ Debt-free Scholar says
I would definitely like to be entered! I am in 11th grade and hoping to get through college frugally.
Baker @ ManVsDebt says
Stephanie, great post! I’ve never heard of this book, but you’ve done a great job of giving us an overview. I definitely wouldn’t mind throwing my name into the drawing for a free copy!
I’m a 20-something with a one year old daughter. By all means it sounds like you should get this into the hands of someone with older children if at all possible. However, as my wife and I fight our War against our $50,000 in student loans I can’t help but want a little better for my daughter.
Great post, keep up the good work!
Thanks for the review. I’d like to enter — I’m in college, and I’d like to see if it’s useful for paying for grad school. I’m on my own after December, and I have no idea where to start, since even the FAFSA is not part of the process.
Great review! It definitely sounds like a great, very useful book that all high school/college students and their parents should get a hand on. I’m a high school senior entering college next year, and it seems like this book has just the tips that might make paying for this amazing opportunity a little bit easier.
i would LOVE to win this book for my son and i. he’s in the 11th grade and is already set on where he wants to go to school and major in. we don’t have much money, but he truly has the drive to makes his dreams come true! I WANNA WIN THIS BOOK!!!
Shellie Seering says
We’re in the midst of all this now. My oldest son is a Junior in HS, and has big dreams for his future. I’d love this book to help me ground him yet help him find his wings. Thanks for sharing with us!
I want to enter the giveaway. I am the parent of 8 children – 3 of whom are already in HS. I need all the help I can get to put them through college so they are not stuck with thousands in debt. Looks like a great tool.
hey steph. count me in. ill take all the advice i can get at this point. im a senior in high school and im in the middle of all these huge decisions…and i dont really want to be up to my eyeballs in debt til im 40 thank you very much.
K. Cleaver says
I would be interested in reading this. We have children in elementary school and have been saving some towards their college. It’s a daunting task.
Thom C says
I’m definately interested in reading this. My son is waffling between a private school ($7000/year after scholarships) and a state school ($4000/year after scholarships). I don’t think he understands what it would mean to be nearly $30000 in debt.
I seriouly am in need of this book (I hope I’m picked!). I’m a college student and I am about to transfer from community college to a 4-year state school. I hope that this book will provide insight into how to get aid from the great(ly broke) state of California, as well as give me some innovative ways to subsidize the costs that I will be incuring in just a matter of months. I could also learn a lot about how to manage the debt that I will soon be in because of the loans I know I will have to take out soon.
eSAT Prep Tips says
I have to say, looking back – I would go to a great (preferably big-name and prestigious, because this seems to count, at least right out of college) state school for a 75% discount on a private education.
Seriously, while I see my education as an invaluable investment, I realize now that I could have been so much more efficient about it.
Any book that promotes this kind of thinking is a great asset in my opinion; a lot of it becomes obvious in retrospect, but the real trick is figuring it out ahead of time and avoiding dumb mistakes.
One smart move for high schoolers is to get a great score on the SAT, which will open up additional scholarship and financial aid doors.
Check out a recent blog post of mine called “How to get a perfect score on the SAT” and browse around for some more great free SAT prep tips!
I haven’t made any comments prior to this one, but this post is some incentive for me to start! I’ve been reading your entries for a few weeks now and am extremely impressed. I’m a finance major and seem similar to you as far as tracking, budgeting, and planning. College has not been one of my strong points, however. I hadn’t formed much knowledge of finances prior to beginning college, so I’ve racked up quite the debt thus far.
With that said, I’d like to enter the contest for this book. I would definitely like to gain some knowledge through the book. Your overview of it makes it seem like a great piece of financial literature. I just turned 21, and while I’ll be done with my undergrad work shortly, I’m going on for an MBA and need to be better prepared for financing that degree. I also would use this book to begin preparation for saving for my (to be born in August) child, once he/she is old enough for college. I guess that puts me in three of the four age recommendations, in their own ways.
Keep up the fantastic work with providing so much useful information for individuals around the world!
Kevin Brown says
Thanks for this. It’s an excellent review on a subject matter that really needed clarification. As a parent of two college-going children, I spent many a sleepless night wondering how I was going to manage to see them both through college. This book would have come in real handy, I can assure you. I just wanted to add that when you have finally short-listed your colleges, speak to their financial aid office at the earliest. Both my kids are enrolled at CollegeAmerica. Their office authorizing financial aid for college has been extremely pro-active. Thanks to their help, a personalized financial plan was drawn up for them. Loan eligibility and the application process is easy, so don’t be afraid to ask for all the help you need.
gap year says
Very informative! And a great run down. But you brushed over gap years quite quickly and I think you could have perhaps mentioned the fact that there is many productive, worthwhile (and lucrative) things people can do on a break that can help them in the immediate term with funds but can also help them get on the career ladder after college